Edit GroupCoalgirls - Fansub Group Information

Go blame Static-Subs (currently 103/122 approval rating) for the original "obliterate" TL before blaming re-release groups.

When they fulfill their dream or whatever and disappear, it's DISAPPEAR NOT "OBLITERATED" WTF IS THIS TRANSLATION?!

They don't care what you think and they choose the shittiest TL for their encodes

@ person in the first red bar "消えろ"　can mean both disappear or destroy

While the file size was ungodly large, one of the perks of a first world country is cheap bandwidth. Superb audio and clear picture.

I was able to find all the episodes for Yuri Yuri whereas the other anime's sites were incomplete or did not have 1080 quality

even using SS's translation, this is worst. Get AtsA's release

Always good translations

quality speed only ones who did it justice

lol coalgirls

nice font, good subs, trust-worthy as always :)

piece of shit losers can't even do a proper encode o0o

Good translations. Keep up with good work. Cheers

Because, like HD

piece of shit losers can't even do a proper encode o0o

(usually) don't sub anything themselves, but they find and put together the best quality videos and subs.

piece of shit losers can't even do a proper encode o0o

Since they used UTW's subs, this can tide people over until someone better who waited for UTW's batch does them.

UTW subs with BD quality

piece of shit losers can't even do a proper encode o0o

A few awkward moments, but overall a very well done sub.

Tenshi's at it again, BloatGirls gonna bloat: "This show seems to compress well. So I added in additional bitrate overkill for 1080p and 720p."

Just go with the 720p.

bloated

Fucking file sizes.

As long as you went with the 720p, you should be fine. It compressed pretty well. And they used Underwater's subs.

Bloatgirls gonna BLOAT!

okay, but there are grammar mistakes sometimes

great 10 bit quality, good font choice

good release

Upvoting to counter repetitive spam.

:) It was a great sub. Sure, sometimes it was kind of dull, but I liked it.

excellent quality and typesetting

8 bit release but worth the enjoyment

piece of shit losers can't even do a proper encode o0o

piece of shit losers can't even do a proper encode o0o

Not so bad, better than I expected and good quality.

BD rip

Translation by [Masterpiece] combined with BD source.

piece of shit losers can't even do a proper encode o0o

BD, Masterpiece subs.

bloatgirls

It's good. it's an upscale, but the quality is still pretty top notch. Uses Ayu's subs. FLAC is a plus. Dual audio. How could you find ANYTHING bad about this?

This is the sub group I chose and it was fine because I just had no subs and used the English dub.

piece of shit losers can't even do a proper encode o0o

piece of shit losers can't even do a proper encode o0o

Looks awesome

Only a couple mistakes in the last 4 episode. Otherwise PERFECT.

Good subtitles (translation+style), amazing video quality, FLAC audio.

Great work

1080p Blu-Ray with FLAC audio releases and high bitrate = win :D

learn to use ordered chapters before using them

shit choice of subs

pretty coal

so many timing issues with their episodes that they refuse to fix in their 720p release. though i do appreciate the BD

Good video, detailed subs

use your damn subs...

qIIq typesetting, Koharubi subs, Blu-ray source. How can someone put negative to this mix?

SHIT ENCODES. Enjoy your eyecancer.

terrible encoding. http://bit.ly/ddhwyL

Blu-ray version but uses Koharubi's subs.

BLOAT Why would I need lossless audio when I'm watching anime?

Timing is off in the 720p version, and the translation is frequently questionable.

All 15 episodes. Perfect in every way. Best 1080p viewing experience.

terrible encoding. http://bit.ly/ddhwyL

They release BD 720p, so they're naturally awesome.

Translated whole season.

Great job!

great Q

Chapters suck and are broken.

fantastic! even did an updated 10bit release not too long ago

eyecancer

don't watch this crap, go with THORA!

Good 720p and all 15 eps subbed.

typesetting is damn annoying and misplaced

Excelent video and audio quality

Messed up audio.

Basically they mixed all the good thing, typeface, tl, karaoke, etc.

quite accurate

Excellent

Very good. But font outline keep changing between with and without outlines...

Block type setting =(

Always good translations.

Good overall. The translation for the ED felt off to me, but that's about the only thing that bothered me about this release.

Perfect in every way imaginable

Very good quality.

This is the best Bakemonogatari release out of all the others. There are only two things that I don't like about this release - the very, very shoddy use of ordered chapters, and the use of FLAC audio.

hi10p

Typesetting is fuckterrible. And are people really complaining about FLAC and filesize in a Coalgirls release? Download the unofficial patch to change the typesetting to gg's and it becomes the best release by miles.

Very high quality subs and editing.

THIS FANSUB IS FULL OF CRAP!!! NOT TOO MENTION IT ALSO GOT VIRUSES!!! SGITTY SUBS GO TO HELL PLS, YOU WILL BURN IN HELL!!! FFS GTFO TYVM

10 bits and excellent quality

hfcfgc

shitgirls

A great series downgraded by poor typesetting and horrific subtitles with a disgusting looking border, I honestly regret watching Coalgirls release.

Loads of translation mistakes. Some of them really made me doubt whether the translator really knows japanese or does she just check words with dictionary word by word...

Did a lot of disruptive write overs.

Clear subbing and great rate of text. Good job team!

A/V quality is fine, most downvoters are just being retards, but typesetting is a complete failure in the 720p release (Example: Ep05 @ 06:44, WTF?)... I haven't watched their 1080p, so I can't comment on that.

Excellent

piece of shit losers can't even do a proper encode o0o

The 720p version is s***, I had to deleted it after only 20 segs because it's until today the only 720p I can't play properly lol, need better encoding

typesetting could have been done a lot better, overall great quality

There's very few errors in the translation.

Flawless encoding as usual. ^^

>Unedited Mazui subs Nope, nope, nope.

good but opening end ending are a little lagging sometime

Great group. Good rips with FLAC audio.

seems accurate and they have 1080p where I download

Wait for someone who actually edits the subs, and thank me after you do so.

nice job

Almost two gigabytes for 20 minutes? Hahaha oh, wow.

High quality release; aesthetically pleasing audio and visual. The plot of the show is shit, however.

piece of shit losers can't even do a proper encode o0o

piece of shit losers can't even do a proper encode o0o

piece of shit losers can't even do a proper encode o0o

piece of shit losers can't even do a proper encode o0o

They always seem to do a good job

piece of shit losers can't even do a proper encode o0o

Great encode!

piece of shit losers can't even do a proper encode o0o

Pure shit!

Pure Awesome!

Epic series in Hi10 and 5.1 surround sound, Awesome

piece of shit losers can't even do a proper encode o0o

Good job translating

i seriously wonder if anybody in this group actually knows how to encode

How do I time

720p is okay for filesize and quality, and the quality is a lot better than in DVD version so I'm happy.

I hate their file sizes as well, but dat quality...

Really huge file size!!!

Raw not from original source, bad encose so the files are large for nothing, also FLAC is an issue. Various playback issues on Windows and Linux.

Files are way too big

pretty stupid to complain about filesize on a hd release if you dislike filesize just go and stream anime in 320p

70GB!

>complaining about file size for an extremely well animated, grainy show

The only one still exist in BakabT

piece of shit losers can't even do a proper encode o0o

High video and audio quality but THORA's release is superior for other reasons. THORA has better subs, better fonts and they actually know how to do OCs properly.

Too big.

dvds + ss-eclipse subs = ???

They're releasing 720p & 1080p, THORA is only 1080p.

unnecessary cropping

awesome quality

Thanks for the great BD!

Between the 3 groups doing BD (CGi, Doki & THOR), CGi has the better video and audio quality of the three groups (high bitrate on video and FLAC audio). Released in HD and Full HD and use SS-Eclipse - whereas THOR use original (which isn't as great)

Not sure if you guys are retarded or what. Each episode is ~550MB and that's for the 1080p bluray release.

Really good

Using higher bitrate to compensate for lack of encoding skills does not result in better video quality. OC's don't work properly. Only good part are the subs, which aren't done by them.

Each episode is too large, 1.7GB

go watch salender-raws or thora

awful encoding. go for THORA!

Superb quality, SS-E subs

QUALITY

Ordered chapters, aghhh... as a Mac user, I don't have many options and I like watching the openings and endings

good release who cares about filesize nowadays?

Simply The Best.

piece of shit losers can't even do a proper encode o0o

The size for the 1080p, the quality, the... everything?

A beautiful show deserves beautiful picture and audio; coalgirls delivered.

Coalgirls somehow manages to do good quality/small filesize with this show. If only they could always be that way.

go watch salender-raws

1080p

piece of shit losers can't even do a proper encode o0o

Haven't seen this, but giving a + to negate the stupid spammer troll.

not bad

piece of shit losers can't even do a proper encode o0o

Haven't seen this, but giving a + to negate the stupid spammer troll.

piece of shit losers can't even do a proper encode o0o

not bad

Haven't seen this, but giving a + to negate the stupid spammer troll.

They don't care what you think and they choose the shittiest TL for their encodes

Koharubi subs...

Blu-Ray HD source encodes, meaning they're also uncensored. Subs are by Koharubi which are decent with a few mistranslations.

piece of shit losers can't even do a proper encode o0o

I tried the 79.5 GB 1080p Blu-Ray remux, but I didn't enjoy the show 6 times as much as I did with the 12.7 GB 720p encode. Or 40 times as much as I did with m33w's 480p TV-rip.

piece of shit losers can't even do a proper encode o0o

Haven't seen this, but giving a + to negate the stupid spammer troll.

Star-sama

piece of shit losers can't even do a proper encode o0o

good subs and very good quality

piece of shit losers can't even do a proper encode o0o

Finally, someone did full Blu-Ray subs for this

"Ilya Sokolov. I think you've heard of her." Two lines later: "He's indeed skilled." Also, encode is pretty bad.

The only BR by a know "group" I could find and it was kick ass. xD

Best BDrips

BD Rips, nice quality overall

piece of shit losers can't even do a proper encode o0o

File Size

Full softsub, as opposed to Ureshii's hardsubbed signs and karaoke.

Ureshii in Bluray. What's not to like? Size doesn't matter; just download, watch, and delete. The best quality you can get, right here.

Bloated, but looks noticeably better than TVrips. Also, full softsub as opposed to Ureshii's hardsubbed signs and songs.

Bloatgirls strikes again.

Enormous file sizes. Where the fuck is this grain they kept blogging about?

Uh, did you watch the video?

piece of shit losers can't even do a proper encode o0o

It's Coalgirls.

so much banding. this is a bd encode, what are you doing?

GotWoot subs with Hi10 (NO BANDING :D) 1080p BD encodes: What's not to love??

With ANE's release out, the only reason to get this is if you're a weeb who wants Mazui or

piece of shit losers can't even do a proper encode o0o

piece of shit losers can't even do a proper encode o0o

Bloatgirls gonna bloat!

So far no spelling and/or grammar mistakes. Also they use a clear font and good text size.

its done well and quality is high but some episodes lag a little but still good

Good quality, used this group cause it's what's available on bakabt ^

BluRay + Official Subs

great

Dunno why people are talking about 1080p... CGi was wise enough to keep this at 720p. It's a studio upscale of an SD show, get G_P or Nanashi if you want 480p.

please learn to encode

Dropped!!!!

retard encoding 101

slow...

enjoy your upscaled shit

AMAZING HD 1080P bluray rips....but really slow

I don't why people are complaining. Other than CoalGirls, the only other group that did the blu-ray version of ES was OZC, in which their video quality, typesetting, and subs are inferior. It seems like people are bitching about this group for the sake of

it's not an upscale, you dumbfuck

Awful 720p bluray rips

Babby's first encode, fucking 30GB for 720p?

Bloatgirls gonna BLOAT!

piece of shit losers can't even do a proper encode o0o

They never go down on quality not on subs and not of video/audio

worse quality than thora months later, worthless

There version 3 encode fixes everything. It's dual audio in HD with a decent file size. The actual video quality is slightly less then thora but you can only notice the difference in a side by side comparison.

crappy quality. go with THORA

rather have the legal dub, it is better

Video quality is the same as THORA. FLAC instead of shitty DTS. Much smaller file size.

Coalgirls are not fansubbers.

piece of shit losers can't even do a proper encode o0o

might as well just download the fucking bluray iso at these sizes

big file size BUT STILL lower quality than Chaos. Way to fail

hard fail

WAY too big

It's 24GB but with equal/lower quality than Chaos-MII

Lol. 9.63GB for the 720p, 23.98GB for the 1080p.

If you read their website you'd know they kept in ALL the grain that Chaos removed.

piece of shit losers can't even do a proper encode o0o

piece of shit losers can't even do a proper encode o0o

Was a good BD release/encode. Uses Eclipse subtitle translation.

piece of shit losers can't even do a proper encode o0o

Great video quality

TRIPLE FLAC AUDIO. HAHAHA, OH WOW

piece of shit losers can't even do a proper encode o0o

^Fuck these guys. Don't want there encode, go get a different one.

piece of shit losers can't even do a proper encode o0o

Eclipse Subs + Blu-Ray goodness = Best edition. Seriously, it's very well done.

one of the few sources to get eclipse-subs (which are even remade)

Excellent work

The quality is much better in this release compared to Elysium. I think CGi used a better source, but the file size is huge because of dual FLAC. Your pick.

piece of shit losers can't even do a proper encode o0o

Victorique still is shit

Unfiltered bloat as usual. Get Victorique, this anime was animated in 540p anyway.

piece of shit losers can't even do a proper encode o0o

Bluray Flac. ANd a good sub

Where did they go?!

Ordered chapters means OP appeared in the first episode, ruining the intro to the show.

Good subbing

Eye cancer.

good subs. show up on time, makes sense, no mistakes.

REMUX GROUP

The best release you'll find. Quality is decent, subtitles are pretty much perfect. Also no problems with ordered chapters either, as one person stated.

ANK-Raws has higher quality.

The font used was clear and I didn't notice any translation errors. Also as always great quality! i definetly recommend the 1080p bluray version. It does take about 53 GB tho but definetly worth it.

Hatsuyuki-Tsuki script, with excellent typesetting, timing and good (slightly bloated) encoding.

A lot of wrong translations, as well as ones I just didn't like. "She doesn't mean that..." shouldn't become "Of course she did". And "That's a lie" becoming "You're pulling my leg" is something I find annoying, because nobody ever says that.

Treats English audio like second-class and cut it out of 720p release because people whined on the blog about space on their 160 GB HDDs. Who designs a BD release for CD-R users?

english audio is second-class

Failed to translate any signs (even ones crucial to plot that are not read aloud) and left a whole line as romaji

The group did not translate some key phrases which were shown on Laptop/Cell phone's screen which made some things un-understandable.

Learn kanji dammit!

No typeset

alot of text in the anime that wasnt translated, you end up missing important parts

Coalgirls = zero effort rips = shit

No translated text on phones/monitors, and there's LOTS of these. Also other various slip-ups.

No on-screen text was translated, better QCing needed.

They didn't sub text messages and the like, only the spoken parts.

Wait.. Did you just say that CoalGirls does not translate? and you approved of their group's "subbing performance"?? i LOL!

They weren't slip ups. They SPECIFICALLY said that they used a "preliminary DB sub" which only have the audio translated which was on 4chan or something. Learn that CoalGirls does not translate.

The translation of the phones is pretty crucial to the show and this was not done. Don't care if it was a prelim sub, they should've v2'd it. Go with someone else.

Not translating on-screen text was very sloppy. There's a lot of it and it's often important.

Good quality, good subs

Untranslated on-screen text that is vital to the story.

Haters didn't notice that CGi has dual-subs: 1st track is gg + honorifics and weeaboo name order, 2nd track is gg original.

encode not good

fail

GG shit is still GG shit

many mistakes

Perfectly watchable.

unnecessary cropping

Removed unnecessary localization done by gg with quality audio and video.

good

Illegal.

Too big

S-Strike~!

Illegal.

a bit slow, but still the best subs for HxH

Not bad , definitely better than Horrible Subs! But replace once [Sg] subs it .

It's good, but [SG] is way better.

the best!!!

Great subbing.

Fast, good quality and low MB files

If not for "evil" sub-rippers, you wouldn't be able to DL DVD/BD quality uncensored releases for a lot of shows. Crymoarplzdiekthx. And how many non-Ryuumaru TLs were available at the time? None!

Thora's doing that too you fool!!

Shit choice of TL

Fucking subrippers.

Styling is kinda fail (color-blending with hair/backgrounds), but good DVD quality, TL from Static, and best non-upscaled h264 version around.

Amazing visual quality

Bloated up Mazui subs

No issue with using Mazui's subs, but not editing them and putting them on that bloated of an encode...

Bloatgirls gonna BLOAT!

tenshi and mazui.

What, you wanted Ayako?

shitty choice of TL

good quality, done right

FLAC audio for a show that's mostly talking, sign translation not as good or thorough as Eclipse.

The encoding is awful.

Only the same brightness errors as every single other encode of the series, since Grand Master Daiz cba to encode it.

colour errors. waaay too bright

I'm not a fan of the sub choice, especially in Ep. 10. Slight trolling and excess vulgarity, otherwise accurate as far as I can tell.

High quality release

Garbage group that is proud to eat the shit SS-Eclipse subs and then dump out their own crap release. Not a fansub group.

timing issues in some episodes

ASS Sub of Eclipse & Static-subs, nice encoding

If you have timing issues, buy a better computer, because your PC jsut can't handle HD video. kkthxbye

didn't like font used in op and ed

timing issues!

blu-ray quality rocks

Timing issues, horrible encoding. Bloat. Won't v2 their mistakes.

fuck the haters

Good quality

The subs are from other groups, but they always mention them. The raws are theirs and the quality is superb.

Good quality, fine translations, fuck all the hating imbeciles..

I'm just used to download their subs always! :D It never dissapoints me.

excellent blu-ray quality.

Great Quality

Huge filesize and the BD upscale problems are still there, also they are still using [gg] subs when gg themselves admitted that the official translation was better than theirs for the most part.

BLOATGIRLS!! they think huge filesize is cool

Huge filesize and the BD upscale problems are still there, also they are still using [gg] subs when gg themselves admitted that the official translation was better than theirs for the most part.

Huge filesize and the BD upscale problems are still there, also they are still using [gg] subs when gg themselves admitted that the official translation was better than theirs for the most part.

Huge filesize and the BD upscale problems are still there, also they are still using [gg] subs when gg themselves admitted that the official translation was better than theirs for the most part.

Huge filesize and the BD upscale problems are still there, also they are still using [gg] subs when gg themselves admitted that the official translation was better than theirs for the most part.

They subbed all the movies. One convenient torrent package provided.

Disregard filesize, watch amazing movie!

bloatgirls

Huge filesize and the BD upscale problems are still there, also they are still using [gg] subs when gg themselves admitted that the official translation was better than theirs for the most part.

Takajun's subs layered on blurays. Smallest file size I've seen for the collection.

Great quality encodes

Better video quality. (obviously)

Huge filesize and the BD upscale problems are still there, also they are still using [gg] subs when gg themselves admitted that the official translation was better than theirs for the most part.

Good subs, but huge file size

Choose their Retail subs as the gg Fansubs for Movie 7 have translation errors. Coalgirls' Retail subs is clear and makes only one mistake by translating a character's name incorrectly.

They did it

Good

6+ Gb. Just "no".

Besides the 2 GB of useless audio tracks it is a decent release, and you can always remove those yourself.

"6+ GB. just no" Complaining about a measly 6GB for 1.5hrs of 1080p lol. Get a decent hard drive, fag.

Garbage group that is proud to eat the shit Mazui subs and then dump out their own crap release. Not a fansub group.

get better encoders

Providing a valuable service, since Mazui typically doesn't do DVD/BD.

Best video quality you can get for this short of buying the blu-ray

Then you are a moralfag, simple as that.

Fucking rippers. I'd rather use a honest supgroup and support 'em than using Coalpussies.

If you like good audio (FLAC is the best currently available), this is the release for you. If you have limited bandwidth, maybe not. The show itself was pretty shit anyways.

Go with [Elysium] for better blu-ray rips.

Using FLAC like a bunch of idiots.

best subs (mazui) + best video (BDRips 1080) = perfect release

Bloatgirls, shit as always

Bad timing, typos, ommited subs.. and since they don't ever never do patches...i guess Mazui TV rips are superior and wait for a decent BD group to do it..

bad encoding for the 1080p

They're the only ones that did the BD, and the subs were amazing (no typos/bad timing like someone said) even if they're ripped from Mazui. As long as they're pleasing some people (like me), I don't see the reason for hating on their release.. if you don'

BloatGirls

Audio and video quality were both amazing, as were the translations (even if they are not CG originals).

Horrible. Get Elysium's release instead if you really need BD quality.

its EPICCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC!!!!

Takes out everything that made the gg subs so entertaining. "Shit TL"? Why use Hatsuyuki (stolen gg subs) instead of gg's originals?

Shit choice of TL

The best 1080p encodes, size was not that big 7.64Gb with FLAC audio. Loved it!

The Ordered Chapters in this were a nightmare.

High end quality videos and perfect subs

Blu-ray.

Oujuu is localized to "beast lords" where Touda remain the same, along with the somewhat rare occurrence of grammatical errors

good bluray release

It's not like there was a wealth of better sub options. Go edit/fix/remux them yourself if you think you can do better. And Ryuumaru's styling, as with most of their releases, was crap.

shit choice of subs

fucked up ryuumaru's nice style. also. terribad editing("what am I doing to do?", seriously?)

Occasional spelling errors in some of their releases, but always good quality

http://www.screenshotcomparison.com/comparison/6473/

Pomf subs, BD quality.

If you're complaining about dual audio, then you're probably archiving on CD-Rs and shouldn't be downloading 1080p in the first place.

1080p and dual audio

1080p and dual audio

Because Coalgirls

Bad translation, bad timing, font is so tiny its not readable, lots of playback problems, get the Seto Otaku (or Thora if you dont mind the size)

just get Commie!

fixed commie

Bloatgirls.

They had good subs with honorifics with good quality best group for this.

>Bloatgirls

Awesomesauce.

Excellent

OMG IM A LAZY FAGGOT WHO CANT CLICK "S" IN MPC TO GET THE SUBS I WANT! And any of these subs are more enjoyable than tri4's ultra-literal nihongo no benkyou junk.

chihiro subs suck

lol chihiro

lol no, get tri4

Bloated release as always, also, Chihiro as the default subs? seriously?

Worst subs on track one; shit encode. Wait for Elysium or tri4 or just use yesy.

Bloated as fuck. Chihiro as sub track 1. Wait for De.us or Elysium.

Chihiro on track one? Nice advertisement kristen. I'll wait for elysium.

Not Meguca.

Best, best, best quality.

good job translating

Not a ridiculous upscale, though the CN audio is a questionable additon. Some may question the choice to use R1 subs, but SS's hardsubs are un-OCRable due to the multiple colors.

Nice upscale and sub stealing

good subs :D

Mardock Scramble: The Non-Compression.

Great job with the translations, even if it is a edited rip. File size would have to be that with all the stuff that happens in there and it's mostly dark all the time

Great but downside was it was too big

Excellent quality

Was later completed, but using delocalized R1 subs + gg's typesetting instead of gg's translations would've produced a better result.

only thing they had going for them and dropped

Erm, they didn't drop. I watched all of Maria Holic with Coalgirls, and everything was perfect. Not a single criticism from me. And I actually preferred the more emotional gg translation over the bland R1 translation.

"Bloatgirls gonna bloat" This isn't a Tenshi encode. 11.78 GB for 720p is perfectly reasonable.

Best Show = Dropped = FAIL

Uses ReinWeiss modifications but doesn't uses gg batch corrections tho. And they can always add in the honorifics.

un-dropped =3

Undropped. Oh gosh... I must download it soon. ξσ_σξ

clean subs :)

Subs devolve into Hadena-tier Engrish as the series goes on, being about as readable as a Hong Kong bootleg. True, Coalgirls just ripped these subs from elsewhere, but that doesn't make them any less shitty.

Using gg subs before they released their own v2 patch that fixes translation errors and removes the trolling, good idea.

Modified gg subs, awesome quality bluray rips.

Blu Ray

Don't let the low vote count get you down. These subs are top quality.

Bloatgirls gonna bloat (BD)

Poor choice of words.

shitty encodes

lol coalgirls

bloat girls

Hooray

bloated

BD. uses UTW subs

BD

"Re-encodes others' subs"? I've never heard of anyone re-encoding a 60 KB .ass file...

dafaq is this? "Whatever was used on our TV-version" just say you were fags that chose CR

They can't place text correctly on the screen.

Highest quality raws, did a good job with the encode.

650mb/ep for the 1080p? enjoy your eyecancer

tney're the only one group that doing it great with no noticeable flaw.

If you can wait nearly a week for these releases, then definitely go with these guys. Very little mistakes, good raw, good job overall.

Why do these folks get so much shit? 650mb/ep for the 1080p is great

greatest quality, always worth the extra DL size file ;)

Excellent translation and editing. Great font.

Good quality, good subs, no translation notes (casuals may not get the jokes), honorifics. Go Coalgirls or Underwater-Commie.

it was the best by far imo

Great sub font and video quality.

BEST nichijou sub of them all. Though there are a few mistakes (what sub wont have them?...), but there isnt too much overtranslation where it doesnt need to be

They didn't drop it. They finished it.

Dropped

Re-re undropped.

Not Dropped

Quality Blu-Ray and good translation.

BD is good.

Blu-Ray rip. Those little things that was slightly censored in the TV version are now for everyone to enjoy.

undropped

The quality was good enough for a first time watch.

dropped

1080p has minor artifacting and isn't really that good, but then again this is the only one that's uncensored... Watch this now, wait for UTW to finish their release for archiving.

decent quality, good translation

top quality bluray release

Good.

WAS good, hopeing it would be finished..maybe...hopefully...just two more episodes......

decent

Great 720p bluray rips

Great

An okay BD release. Too bad the subs they chose call her "Horo," though.

bad encode

Great subs.

yes

no...

shitty encode

Bloatgirls shit as always

Massive bitrate in an attempt to get rid of the easily filtered banding. What are you doing, Kristen?

Since when has one of CoalGirls' releases *not* used subs taken from somewhere else? Blame MAL for being dumb and labeling all anime release groups as "fansubbers."

Cry more, newfags.

Rips.

shit

I'm not sure why they did such a bad job, it was not hard to improve on Mazui but they failed again.Go with Mazui even if the typesetting is bad

wtf are you serious?! stolen subs

Best release out there. Higher quality video although the subs are ripped from Mazui.

not good

my head exploded with this horrible choice of TL ... ss>mazui

Good quality for a good show.

coalgays

Haters gonna hate... BD with Mazui subs, nuff said

Significantly better availability.

decent rip, decent subs, good torrent availability

"Who picks Commie?" Clearly a smart person who realizes that Commie's subs were THE ONLY ONES AVAILABLE.

who is the dumb nigga that picks commie?

The best!!!

BluRay with Inferno subs, saikoo... arigatou CoalGirls ~sukanime

How many subs were available other than Underwater's Viz-edits or further edits thereof? Oh that's right, none.

over liberalized choice of shitty subs

43 GiB for 12 episodes. It's not even funny.

too many script errors to be tolerated on a blu-ray release

Bloatgirls gonna bloat

Yes, it's easy to be one of the best "subbers" when you use someone else's subs (Nuke in this case).

No doubt one of the best subbers.

"Dropped" is a positive, it was a shit source anyway, and all CGi would've done with it was throw moar bitrate at problem areas. 'Cause filtering destroys irrelevant "important" details.

Dropped!!!!!

Two bloated FLAC tracks for a show that's nothing but talking. Fail.

Great job.

BLOATED!

Huge file size, average quality. Grainy scenes are unwatchable; they skip and judder. This group doesn't know how to encode.

Another bloated shit by ShitHeads

"Cola" or "Here" ?

uhhh 10 gb or 20 gb, no one wins

Large files

Large file size, but great quality!

They used gleam, ayako and doremi fan sub with HD qualty

Great quality! The one who says it's unsynchronized is DOING IT WRONG.

Awesome quality blu ray

If only Funimation could have preserved the correct brightness from the Japanese box set like Coalgirls did.

love there subbing always have always will

Coalbanding...

1080p quality

blueray and such

Lovely BluRay rips

VLC problems can be corrected by using MPC-HC. Enjoyed the BD.

Awesome quality

HD

Audio and video would be unsynchronized at times

1080

They did a great job with video compression, however, their attempt to preserve the dvd chapters can cause some problems in VLC which does not fully support this function.

Jap and Eng audio also good quality

Once had the best encode quality but no longer does

1080p, good subs

Bloated

Good Quality!

The video quality is BLU-RAY .FLAC, so it's hardly a surprise the raw quality is good. Not sure if they do the subbings themselves or if the rips include them, but they're fine.

One of Coalgirls' most impressive releases.

I watched the whole thing in 1080p except the last episode and special 21.5. Pretty good quality !

@ "Awful subs" - what should they have done, OCRed/transcribed 22 episodes of Shinsen's hardsubs? They're the official R1DVD subs, learn to live with a little localization for once.

This is the group I came across but I appreciate the job they've done!

Horrible! Awful subs.

piece of shit losers can't even do a proper encode o0o

I liked their lame squid puns.

It's Coalgirls.

nice

bad encodes, huge filesize

wtf did he encode with xvid4psp? lul

High quality BDrip ; )

Bloated FLACebo-quality audio, trolls leechers with bloated 1080p encodes on a show that's barely worth 720p.

Video is nice albeit bloated on 720p. Subs are horrible however.

nice and neat

taking forever, too slow

Bloatgirls gonna BLOAT!

used bd subs. were fine

There is no such thing as "correct" name order. Only the name order you personally prefer, and the order you don't prefer.

UN-FABULOUS

worsified rips

Broke what's not broken.

I don't see how getting rid of the ridiculous CMs and reverting back to correct name order and proper honorifics while still using the same translation could possibly be a bad thing...

Better quality than gg and removes some of the trolling. Translation is still meh, but I'm giving it a plus since it's at least preferrable to gg's version.

adding honorifics to shitty tl still equals shitty tl

Dropped. I was hoping to get a version with honorifics, but I guess not. Sigh...Maybe when the BD's come out...

- gg Liberal Shit

Mistranslations.

IF YOU WANT HONORIFICS EDIT THE SCRIPT YOURSELF YOU FUCKING LAZY CUNTS. MKVMERGE ISN'T HARD TO USE.

THEY REMOVED THE FABULOUS

They didn't "fix" anything. Just added honorifics, used a different synonym for fabulous and mistranslated Ginga Bishounen.

lolwut

Bluray video, Flac Audio, Good translations and styled subs!

where are all the commie haters now? "they even translate their own releases", etc? same shit here. and bloat. Cgi's ep 2 has over 100MB than gg release. "fixed" subs are that heavy?

It's GG... only they fixed up everything that faGGots did wrong. So of course it's better!

well xD

Only changing naming convention, remove fabulous, and mistranslating Ginga Bishounen. All other gg's so called "localization" still exists.

its the same shit with gg, same shitty TL, only un-fabulous

BluRay

NO KIRABOUSHI

Don't you know? Filtering destroys important detail like stars, wood grains, wall dirt, and rock textures, which are what everyone watches anime for these days.

best

BDs

Dropped

Dropped so far along in the series.

Looked like an unfiltered banded mess, then they dropped it. And nothing of value was lost.

Dropped it

Too lazy to retype and retime the hardsubbed song lyrics from StrikeSubs' DVD release, resulting in untranslated songs.

doesnt know how to encode

nothing to complain, also BD!

It's good. BD and best subs available, lyrics are definitely negligible. Full of win ^^

Just how many translations were available for this show, other than Underwater? Oh that's right, none! And unless you're obsessed with honorifics, the TL is just fine.

Shit choice of TL with shit encode

Just like S1, BD quality. Files are HUGE, though...

files are quite big. They used Underwater Subs(good choice).

Good source of BDs with good subs, but 3GB an episode is steep even with 2TB to work with D:

bloated

Basically a ripoff of Underwater's release with more bloat and less-readable subs. Don't waste your bandwidth.

The release is bigger than Underwater, but a huge improvement. If you can't afford a new HD, don't negative vote a group you didn't watch

Yay! Bloatgirls gonna *B*L*O*A*T*

encode bad

decent subs and great quality mkv :D

Get Doki.

Hallelujah, I don’t know much of the grammar but at least it’s no lol’cam anymore. Thank You Guys.

The banding is in the source. If you try to get rid of it like Mazui did all you do is kill the fine details.

Get Mazui's encode from the BDMV. It took them a while to release a proper encode but the quality shows. Much better than doki's or coalgirls.

Terrible banding.

Good quality video with flac audio

Good encode, no problems with banding.

LOL Bloatgirls trying to mingle in this too, just fuck off

inferior to delicio.us

You only read this because it's read. Now that I have your attention, it's between Coalgirls and Doki. Both subs are great, it's alla bout YOUR tastes. So quit relying on these comments -.-

Good release.

Garbage group that is proud to eat the shit Ayako subs and then dump out their own crap release. Not a fansub group.

ayako best group for this release

They had an exellent bluray quality

did a good job.

Great work on Ayako's subs. Best group to use ^^

Would've preferred 480p, but 720p was all right and nobody else released these anyway.

Useless mkv crap.

mkv-tard

>useless mkv HAHAHA OH WOW what a faggot

how stupid someone must be to call mkv «crap»? go the f*** back in 80s and watch your cozy VHS xD

there was this word. "gallumbal"

No, just no

no... Subsmith!

FLAC

The encoding is awful

piece of shit losers can't even do a proper encode o0o

Great work

Bloated upscaled 1080placebo "quality." At least they stopped ripping JC Staff (=540p) shows at 1080p after this.

l2encode

Upscales

1080p looks worse than THORA's 720p encode.

Large files, justified by excellent quality.

1080p

bloated

Good quality

Good subs, but OP and ED are cut.

Ordered fucking chapters!

Good quality, that's all....

blu-ray encodes with utw subs

I guess

Fucking ordered chapters.

DVD version is good quality and not upscaled. Uses the best subs (gg/qq/coalguys) while fixing most of the errors, like the trolling and in-jiokes in coalguys' subs.

they were actually decent subs

lol fail upscales

only good release coalgirls has done

good work

nice upscales

fail choice of subs, retards

They used the DVDs when they came out. So DL those instead of the upscales.

Upscales... Toradora! never aired in HD (720/1080)

Awesome!!

voice and video are completely out of sync

Coalguys did a great job, this group is using their name to advance their own succes. BAH!

Good enough quality and used a combination of subs.

They're shit

I liked the subs

THey did an outstanding job, although they didn't have any information bubbles popping up when traditional japanese stuff appeared.

Best release.

Can't comment on translation but i had no issues with this group

I had no problems with this release.

The font they use it's awesome. Accurate and no errors.

Because they're Coalgirls.

Only DVD's. Just use Doki's ver. if you want to see BD.

Love the BD

Although there are quite a bit of mixed opinion about Coalgirls, I think they did a pretty good job with Toradora! There are a few engrish here and there but otherwise it's a good release.

Awesome quality, love the BD release. Get Coalgirls, it's the best. Doki isn't even completed with their Toradora! Blu-Ray. This was an awesome release. No issues so far with CGi.

The BluRays are spectacular.

good subs

good quality and subs/typesetting do not fail

If 1080i sources get encoded at a maximum of 720p, why don't 720i sources like this get taken down to 480p/576p?

thora does a better job (as seen in some comparison pictures)

It's great. I don't see why people don't vorte for this one. :/

High quality.

Better than, or occasionally just as good as, THORA's release.

!

Good translations.

If 1080i sources get encoded at a maximum of 720p, why don't 720i sources like this get taken down to 480p/576p?

hideous encode

LOLKRISTEN

Blu-ray 1080p FTW!!! Also great subs...

meh...

1980x1020 really brought out the beautiful character design white album has to offer.

terrible eyecancerous encode.

perfect translation and their quality is always perfect.

"Shit choice of TL"... just like, I don't know, almost every other group that used the UTW-Ryuumaru subs?

Shit choice of TL, you disgust me

derp.

Excellent quality.

What, you'd rather have Ayako's fail editing? Cgi removed the "vagina bones" line, so the main thing people whined about from gg's subs is gone. Too bad they made the timing more "fragmented," though.

I would of expected a shitty TL choice from tenshi but coalgirl choosing GG is unforgivable

Very decent release. Good quality and not-bad-at-all subs.

best quality

1080p video with no details to warrant it, bitrate overkill with no action to warrant it, FLAC audio bloat for nothing but talking. If this is how 2012 encodes are "supposed" to be, count me out.

1080p Blu-Ray with FLAC audio, high bitrate and Hi10P. This is what 2012 encodes should be. 8 bit encodes are a thing of the past.

Doesn't even bother to correct Kyouko's name. And it's ordered chapters

Hi10p

hi10

Learn to encode.

10bit is good but not when it looks worse than CR rips

Quality subs and video

wow, how the fuck did you managed to make Hi10p look worse than HorribleSubs encodes

Seems to be better than SHiN-gx's.

Besides the bleed in the OP/ED subs, it's the best sub for the series.

Good translation and 10-bit encoding, but the ordered chapters are annoying.

The best.

Usually bad but for YRYR was actually good.

best out there

Ordered chapters worked, but the video was eye cancer.

Hi10p

High detailed, low file size. Warning: they use Hi10p

Hi10P.

One of the earliest uses of hi10bit encoding we see, and it's an effective display. Add to that ordered chapters with external opening and ending, and it makes for some outstandingly small file sizes with no quality loss. HOWEVER, releases are rather slow

1080P KYOKO GOODNESS

Excellent job, hope to see more from this group in the future

Hi10p is fucking great. I mean, three of the episodse don't even reach 100mb with no loss in quality. Also Coalgirls release much more quickly than SHiN-gX. Best group for this show.

looks GOOD

good quality video and nice subs

Everything is done well.

good quality

good subs

coalgirls

Subs were fantastic and unobtrusive, plus correct.

Better than the rest atm