Gintama is overrated

A club for those of us who know that Gintama isn't; has never been and never will be; the greatest anime of all time or even a candidate for that title.

Come on now, this is supposed to be the best anime ever made? It even admits itself that Naruto and One Piece are better.

The reasons for thinking this show is overrated may vary from member to member. Some might think it's good but far from a masterpiece and some might hate it from the bottom of their hearts. Whoever you are, if you can think of at least 50 titles that are better than Gintama, you're welcome here.

Also, this club only covers the anime. Since the manga don't seem to be equally popular. But you are of course free to bitch about the manga too.

Club Members

Club Pictures

Displaying 1 of 1 topics | See All
Club Discussion
What's your opinion on Gintama?
bergdoll - Sep 4, 2011
5 replies by MachoGoose »»
Jun 26, 2013 9:05 AM

Club Comments
Isterio | May 26, 2:22 PM
It´s a good show and has delivered the best comedy I´ve seen in Anime, still it has extremely weak momments which should get taken into consideration.

I think of it as a cencored version of japanese South Park.

bergdoll | Oct 13, 2012 4:04 PM
Maybe. A little. Yeah, probably a little. Not in an insulting way though. Or maybe a little... Meh. Whatever. I'm pretty sure everyone in here knows how MAL's rating system works. Right Butler and Battler? Lol, just came up with an awesome new title for the club: Bergdoll's Butler Battlers against Bizarrely Overrated Gintama! BBBBOG for short.

Yes. I'm tired.

MachoGoose | Oct 12, 2012 8:02 PM
Well, not trying to be rude, but it's kind of annoying how an anime managed to get to number 1 by just having a huge fanbase almost instantly assuming it's going to be the most awesome anime on the face of the planet. That's how I see it, please don't throw anything at me.

Carlos-Sakata | Oct 12, 2012 3:16 AM
Are you laughing at me?

bergdoll | Oct 11, 2012 7:11 AM
I find nothing to disagree with in the previous comment. THE END!

Carlos-Sakata | Oct 11, 2012 3:40 AM
People score the series with his judgement, and then myanimelist makes an average of all scores. If Gintama is the first, is because people voted with the highest score. THE END.

NaruhodouBattler | Oct 9, 2012 3:31 PM
It's better to be 8.3 or less...

bergdoll | Oct 8, 2012 4:32 PM
Yay, new members! :D

Anyway, most fans just gave it the same score as previous seasons and thus the ranking. Oh and it won't go down anytime soon (unless troll accounts spam 1/10) due to the length- and double sequel boost.

Club Stats
Members: 23
Pictures: 3
Category: Anime
Created: Sep 4, 2011

Club Officers
bergdoll (Creator)

Club Type
This is a public club. Anyone can join and invite others to join.

Anime Relations